news

Why Suing Your Neighbour Over A Flat Sale Backfires So Often

Chasing an £80,000 payout over a collapsed flat sale sounds tempting until the court hands you a £180,000 bill. That's what happened to London professor Daslav Brkic and his wife after their bitter

Why Suing Your Neighbour Over A Flat Sale Backfires So Often
In this story

Chasing an £80,000 payout over a collapsed flat sale sounds tempting until the court hands you a £180,000 bill. That's what happened to London professor Daslav Brkic and his wife after their bitter row with freeholder and upstairs neighbour Douglas Palin went to trial.

Brkic claimed Palin's comments about past property disputes scared off a prospective buyer and made their £680,000 Finsbury Park flat unsellable. Judge Nigel Gerald wasn't buying it. He dismissed the £80,000 claim, found Palin had acted within his rights by sharing factual concerns on a Leasehold Property Enquiries form, and ruled there wasn't enough proof that those disclosures caused the buyer to walk away.

To make matters worse, the couple were ordered to pay Palin's estimated £45,000 legal costs (including £30,000 up front within 28 days) on top of roughly £135,000 in their own legal fees. Spending £180,000 trying to recover £80,000 is a brutal lesson in how UK property litigation works.

http://googleusercontent.com/lmdx_content/dwaXRWwJyITyBCbZPKdrFVaRrFdvDToWbNrKWrVLRQBqGSZsZeRGAqQltjExVcGpFsbSmmbcoNtuHpAkgduncokgbWmvjGpsqGWsSzehpgXERNfXkstUVubxJQogOxQQDWSYHTkjuQywfDRZisYFUfqZIhomrYxrwAfDfORct118653

How a Victorian Flat Sale Turned Into a £180,000 Nightmare

Period conversions in London are notorious flashpoints. When Brkic and his wife bought the ground-floor and garden flat in a Victorian building on Alexandra Grove in Finsbury Park back in 2013, they stepped into a shared-building dynamic where every alteration affects someone else. Palin, a wine retailer who owned the freehold and lived upstairs, clashed with them over refurbishment work involving flooring, windows, burglar bars, and electrical cabling.

In 2021, Palin took the couple to a tribunal over removed carpets that breached the lease. The tribunal sided with Palin on that point, and the couple later re-carpeted the flat to address noise nuisance, though Palin lost a separate tribunal hearing over repeated inspections.

When the couple tried to sell in 2023, things unraveled fast. An early £680,000 offer fell through, and a second buyer who offered around £640,000 pulled out in August. Brkic blamed Palin's entries on a Leasehold Property Enquiries form—mentioning the resolved carpet row, window and burglar-bar disagreements, and a bathroom boundary mix-up—for tanking the deal.

Judge Gerald saw a very different picture. Palin raised genuine concerns, such as whether swapping sash windows for UPVC harmed the building's character and value, and there was no dishonesty or bad faith. Even more damning for the claim, the buyers appeared to have walked away before even receiving Palin's comments, and most disputes had already been resolved by August 2024. The court also noted the couple hadn't disclosed certain issues in their own property and leasehold forms.

What Freeholders and Neighbours Can Actually Say During a Sale

A lot of leaseholders assume a neighbour or freeholder is gag-ordered from mentioning friction while a flat is on the market. Honestly, that's a dangerous myth.

When conveyancing enquiries go out—such as Leasehold Property Enquiries (LPE1)—freeholders and managing agents are routinely asked about breaches, complaints, alterations, and disputes. Sharing accurate, historical facts or genuine building concerns without malice isn't automatically an actionable wrong just because a seller hates the tone.

Still, there's a big difference between stating factual history and making defamatory statements or lying. If someone invents fake legal actions or spreads outright falsehoods with malice, that's another ballgame. When a freeholder flags a real lease dispute, an unapproved window change, or a documented complaint, courts generally treat that as part of the messy reality of leasehold ownership rather than an illegal sabotage plot.

Why Sellers Lose Misrepresentation and Sabotage Claims

Suing a neighbour because a buyer got cold feet is one of the hardest uphill battles in property law. Courts look for causation—hard proof that the neighbour's statement actually caused the buyer to pull out, rather than mortgage rate shifts, survey worries, chain collapses, or simple buyer second thoughts.

In the Brkic case, the timeline hurt the claim badly. If buyers withdraw before seeing the disputed comments, you can't credibly argue those comments killed the offer. And as property dispute guidance on TA6 disclosures explains, sellers face serious legal exposure under the Misrepresentation Act 1967 when they omit or gloss over disputes on their own forms.

Here's the uncomfortable truth about selling a flat with a history of friction:

  • Buyers spook easily on leasehold risks. Even a resolved dispute raises questions about service charges, management friction, and future legal headaches.
  • Your own paperwork gets scrutinized. If a seller leaves gaps in their Property Information Form or leasehold replies while accusing someone else of over-sharing, credibility takes a hit.
  • Legal costs dwarf modest claims. In civil litigation, paying both your own lawyers and part of the winner's bill can easily double or triple the amount you were fighting over.

Practical Steps Before You List a Flat With Past Disputes

If you're selling a leasehold flat and you've ever clashed with a freeholder or neighbour, don't wait until an offer collapses to deal with the fallout. Get ahead of it early.

  1. Audit your paperwork before marketing. Go through your lease, alterations history, tribunal decisions, and draft TA6 or leasehold forms with a conveyancing solicitor so past issues are addressed accurately and consistently.
  2. Gather written proof of resolutions. Keep copies of settled complaints, completed works, and sign-offs so buyers can see problems were closed out rather than left hanging.
  3. Check alterations and permissions early. Make sure flooring, windows, fixtures, and layouts match lease terms and building consents before a buyer's surveyor or freeholder raises them.
  4. Run a cost-benefit check before suing. Talk to a litigation specialist about prospects, causation proof, and likely legal fees—because winning a point on principle won't pay a six-figure court bill.
AJ

Written by

Antonio Jones

Antonio Jones is an award-winning writer whose work has appeared in leading publications. Specializes in data-driven journalism and investigative reporting.

More from news