news

Why Israel's Election Deadlock Goes Much Deeper Than Netanyahu And Eisenkot

Israel's latest national election ended exactly where so many political observers feared it would: nowhere. Exit polls and early counts show Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s right-wing bloc and

Why Israel's Election Deadlock Goes Much Deeper Than Netanyahu And Eisenkot
In this story

Israel's latest national election ended exactly where so many political observers feared it would: nowhere. Exit polls and early counts show Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s right-wing bloc and Gadi Eisenkot’s centrist opposition neck and neck, with neither securing the 61-seat parliamentary majority needed to build a government.

If you're looking at the numbers and feeling a sense of déjà vu, you aren't alone. We’ve seen coalition gridlock in Jerusalem before. But viewing this race simply as a referendum on Netanyahu’s political survival misses the seismic structural shift happening underneath Israeli society.

The real story isn't just that Netanyahu and Eisenkot fell short. It's that the traditional mathematical paths to forming a government in Israel have completely fractured.

The Mathematical Math Problem Facing Jerusalem

To form a government in the 120-seat Knesset, you need 61 votes. Simple arithmetic, right? Except the political terrain following October 7 and three years of regional conflict makes standard math impossible. To understand the full picture, check out the excellent analysis by Associated Press.

Netanyahu’s camp—comprising Likud, ultra-Orthodox parties like Shas and United Torah Judaism, and far-right nationalist factions led by Itamar Ben-Gvir and Bezalel Smotrich—hovered around 52 to 54 seats in initial exit polling. That leaves them short of the magic number.

On the other side, Eisenkot’s newly minted Yashar party and its centrist and left-wing partners face an even stickier tactical problem. While their combined numbers look comparable on paper, their coalition relies on a fragile patchwork. To cross 61, the anti-Netanyahu bloc requires either the backing of ultra-nationalist hawkish figures like Avigdor Liberman—who refuses to sit in any government with ultra-Orthodox parties—or cooperation with Arab-led parties like Ra'am.

Eisenkot, a former IDF Chief of Staff who lost his son and two nephews in Gaza, campaigned on creating a "Zionist government of national service." That explicit focus immediately creates friction with Arab lawmakers, making a stable, lasting governing pact almost impossible to construct.

Basically, neither side has a natural route to power.

Why This Race Was Different

Most international coverage framed this vote as a simple choice between Netanyahu’s staying power and Eisenkot’s promise of broad institutional reform. That framing leaves out three huge factors that shaped how Israelis actually voted.

The Draft Mandate

For decades, the ultra-Orthodox (Haredi) exemption from mandatory military service was a political bargaining chip passed quietly between coalitions. Not anymore. With the military stretched thin after years of multi-front security operations, the draft became the central political fault line of 2026.

Secular and national-religious voters demanded an end to universal exemptions. Meanwhile, ultra-Orthodox leaders made draft protection a non-negotiable precondition for joining any coalition. Netanyahu remains locked into protecting his Haredi allies, while Eisenkot built his platform around universal national service. This single issue makes a cross-bloc compromise incredibly difficult.

The Arab Voter Surge

Turnout in Arab-Israeli communities, which hovered near historic lows in previous election cycles, saw a notable surge. Protests over domestic security and economic neglect drove voters to the polls in Nazareth, Sakhnin, and Kafr Qasim.

While Netanyahu attempted to rally his base by warning of high turnout in Arab towns, the increased participation boosted Arab-led factions to roughly 17 to 18 seats. That turns them into indispensable political players, even as major Zionist parties hesitate to invite them into a formal cabinet.

Security Consensus, Tactical Division

Don't confuse political polarization with a split on national security. Across the main Jewish-led parties, there is broad agreement on tough policies regarding Iran's nuclear infrastructure and opposition to a Palestinian state.

Where Netanyahu and Eisenkot truly diverge is governance and trust. Eisenkot campaigned on repairing diplomatic relations with Washington, reforming judicial checks and balances, and restoring institutional norms. Netanyahu framed the election as a clear mandate to finish his national security agenda and defeat regional adversaries "once and for all."

What Happens Now

The election is over, but the actual fight for power is just beginning. President Isaac Herzog will host formal consultations with every party that crossed the 3.25% electoral threshold.

Herzog will task the candidate he believes has the best chance of forming a coalition with a 28-day window to negotiate, expandable by 14 days.

Here are the realistic scenarios on the table right now:

  1. The Caretaker Loophole: If neither Netanyahu nor Eisenkot can pull together 61 votes, Israel heads right back to the polls for another election. In the meantime, Netanyahu stays in office as caretaker prime minister. For a leader managing ongoing legal challenges and complex diplomatic maneuvers, staying in the prime minister's chair without a permanent coalition is still a tactical win.
  2. A Rogue Faction Flips: Small, single-issue parties hold enormous leverage right now. A sudden compromise on Haredi enlistment or judicial reform could prompt a minor party to cross aisle lines, giving one side a razor-thin 61-seat coalition.
  3. A Broad Unity Compromise: Pressure from Washington and internal economic strain could theoretically force a emergency national unity government. Given the deep personal animosity between the camp leaders, though, don't hold your breath.

Israel's political deadlock isn't a temporary glitch; it's the current baseline of its electoral system. Until the country addresses the fundamental divide over military service, institutional checks, and coalition arithmetic, victory at the ballot box will remain an illusion.

NC

Written by

Naomi Campbell

A dedicated content strategist and editor, Naomi Campbell brings clarity and depth to complex topics. Committed to informing readers with accuracy and insight.

More from news