news

Why Gadi Eisenkot Faces An Uphill Battle To Replace Netanyahu

The political stalemate in Jerusalem just took a decisive turn. Israel’s President Isaac Herzog has officially tapped Gadi Eisenkot, leader of the center-right Yashar party, to form the nation's next

Why Gadi Eisenkot Faces An Uphill Battle To Replace Netanyahu
In this story

The political stalemate in Jerusalem just took a decisive turn. Israel’s President Isaac Herzog has officially tapped Gadi Eisenkot, leader of the center-right Yashar party, to form the nation's next government.

Following last month’s election where Benjamin Netanyahu lost his governing majority, the mandate has shifted to the former military chief. But getting the mandate and actually assembling a working majority in a fractured 120-seat Knesset are two completely different things.

If you're watching the headlines, it looks like Netanyahu’s record-breaking run as prime minister is finally crashing down. The reality on the ground is far messier, and Eisenkot's path forward is littered with political landmines.

The Numbers Game inside the Knesset

The math coming out of the October 27 election created an immediate gridlock. Netanyahu’s religious-nationalist coalition secured 53 seats, remaining the largest single bloc but falling well short of the 61-seat threshold needed to govern. On the other side, Eisenkot’s broad anti-Netanyahu opposition bloc pulled together 48 seats.

Neither traditional coalition has an easy route to power. That leaves the remaining seats held by Arab-majority parties in the role of unexpected kingmakers.

During formal consultations at the president's residence, both Arab lists threw their official endorsement behind Eisenkot. That endorsement convinced Herzog to hand the mandate to the Yashar leader rather than Netanyahu. Yet, endorsing a candidate to form a government isn't the same as joining a coalition.

Eisenkot hasn't agreed to formally bring Arab parties into his cabinet. Doing so would alienate right-wing members of his own coalition who refuse to sit in a government dependent on Arab party votes. If he rejects them, he runs out of numbers. It's a classic Israeli political trap.

Who is Gadi Eisenkot

For readers outside Israel, Gadi Eisenkot isn't your typical politician. He built his career over decades inside the Israel Defense Forces, serving as IDF Chief of Staff from 2015 to 2019.

He carries a reputation for being pragmatic, unpolished, and intensely focused on security. During the 2006 Lebanon War, he formulated the "Dahiya doctrine"—a military strategy advocating the application of overwhelming force against civilian and military infrastructure in areas controlled by hostile armed groups like Hezbollah.

Political analysts often label him a moderate simply because he opposes Netanyahu's far-right allies. But don't mistake him for a dove.

💡 You might also like: five star inn west covina
  • He explicitly opposes the creation of a Palestinian state under current conditions.
  • He supports aggressive military action to destroy Hamas's armed capabilities in Gaza.
  • He has publicly denounced violent extremist settlers in the West Bank, calling their attacks "Jewish terror" and accusing Netanyahu's cabinet of turning a blind eye.

Eisenkot positions himself as a unifying national figure who can restore institutional norms without sacrificing national security. Whether that message appeals to enough right-wing lawmakers to build a cabinet remains unproven.

Three Ways This Mandate Could Play Out

Eisenkot has 28 days to build a coalition, with the possibility of a two-week extension if Herzog grants it. Here is how the next month will likely unfold:

1. The National Emergency Coalition

Eisenkot’s preferred outcome—and his immediate public rally on X—is a broad "national emergency government." To pull this off, he needs to peel away moderate right-wing members currently aligned with Netanyahu or convince religious parties to ditch their long-standing alliance with Likud. It's a high-stakes gamble that requires coaxing seasoned politicians away from Netanyahu's camp.

2. An External Support Agreement

Eisenkot could form a minority government with 50 to 55 seats and rely on Arab-majority parties to support the coalition from the outside on key confidence votes. This model was used during the Bennett-Lapid government in 2021. However, keeping such a fragile setup alive during active military tensions or domestic unrest is nearly impossible for long stretches.

3. Failure and a Fifth Election Cycle

If Eisenkot fails to lock down 61 votes, the mandate returns to the Knesset. If no other candidate can build a government within 21 days, parliament automatically dissolves, sending Israelis back to the ballot box for another exhausting election cycle.

What to Watch Next

The coming days will move fast. The official ceremony at the president's residence on Sunday marks the formal start of the clock.

Keep a close eye on the smaller right-leaning factions within Eisenkot's orbit. Their willingness to compromise on budget issues, civil reforms, and Arab party cooperation will determine whether Israel gets a new prime minister or heads straight back to political paralysis.

RH

Written by

Ryan Henderson

Ryan Henderson combines academic expertise with journalistic flair, crafting stories that resonate with both experts and general readers alike.

More from news