news

Why Clearing The Fairview Encampment In Penticton Solves Nothing

Courts can issue injunctions, but concrete asphalt doesn't absorb human beings when you sweep them out of sight. Another camp is coming down. The B.C. Supreme Court recently granted an injunction

Why Clearing The Fairview Encampment In Penticton Solves Nothing
In this story

Courts can issue injunctions, but concrete asphalt doesn't absorb human beings when you sweep them out of sight.

Another camp is coming down. The B.C. Supreme Court recently granted an injunction allowing the province to clear out the Fairview homeless encampment in Penticton, situated on Ministry of Transportation land between Highway 97 and Ellis Creek. Residents have a strict deadline to pack up and get out.

Local businesses are breathing a sigh of relief. Property owners nearby have dealt with break-ins, anxiety, and dangerous fires—including a severe blaze last May that sent black smoke into the air and another last year that jumped to the adjacent Leisureland RV Centre, destroying two recreational vehicles. Business operators like Luke Bradley admit they are exhausted by the constant fear of property damage.

Yet, wiping an encampment off the map doesn't make the people living there disappear. It just shuffles them down the road.

The Reality of Moving Day

When Justice Breanna Hardwick ruled that the Fairview site presented a significant public safety risk unsuitable for outdoor sheltering, she addressed the physical hazards of the camp. Fires, clutter, and proximity to major infrastructure highways are undeniable liabilities.

What the court order failed to address is where about a dozen displaced individuals are supposed to sleep tomorrow night.

Casper, a resident of the Fairview encampment, put it bluntly when speaking about the cycle of displacement. Packing up belongings at a moment's notice only to search for a temporary patch of grass before morning bylaws force another move is exhausting. It wears people down to the bone. For Casper and others facing the Friday noon deadline, compliance isn't guaranteed. Some residents have stated they will stay put until police step in with handcuffs, hoping to force public attention onto a broken system.

📖 Related: this story

The Shelter Gap in the Okanagan

You cannot evict people into thin air if you expect an urban crisis to improve.

Julius Bloomfield, Penticton's outgoing mayor, pointed out the obvious flaw in treating court injunctions as a permanent fix. Existing local shelters are entirely full. There is no surplus capacity waiting to absorb a dozen newly displaced campers. When municipal and provincial authorities secure court orders without pairing them with immediate, accessible housing options, they are simply playing an endless game of musical chairs with human lives.

Businesses get temporary peace of mind. Property owners feel safer from accidental fires and break-ins. But the underlying engine driving people into tents along Ellis Creek—severe housing shortages, poverty, and a lack of specialized mental health and addiction support—remains entirely untouched.

Clearing a patch of dirt doesn't solve homelessness. It just moves the human cost somewhere else out of view until the next court date arrives.

DR

Written by

Daniel Reed

Drawing on years of industry experience, Daniel Reed provides thoughtful commentary and well-sourced reporting on the issues that shape our world.

More from news